Procedures for Dealing with Complaints and Appeals

Advances in the Theory of Nonlinear Analysis and its Application welcomes feedback and handles every complaint and appeal fairly, confidentially and in a timely manner, following COPE guidance.

Making a complaint

Anyone may inform the Editor-in-Chief, members of the Editorial Board or the publisher of a concern about the journal, its processes or a published article, by writing through the Contact page. The complaint should clearly describe the issue and include supporting evidence. Complaints will be acknowledged and the complainant kept informed of progress.

Appeals against editorial decisions

Authors who believe that their manuscript was rejected on the basis of a misunderstanding or error may submit an appeal to the Editor-in-Chief, explaining in detail the reasons for the appeal and responding point by point to the reviewers' comments. The Editor-in-Chief may consult another member of the Editorial Board or an additional reviewer. The decision on the appeal is final. Only one appeal per manuscript is considered, and the manuscript must not be submitted elsewhere while the appeal is under consideration.

Investigation

The Editor-in-Chief, in consultation with the Editorial Board and the publisher where needed, decides whether an investigation is necessary. Evidence is collected confidentially, and the party concerned is given an opportunity to respond.

Minor Misconduct

Cases of minor misconduct, arising from a misunderstanding or misapplication of publishing standards, may be dealt with directly with the persons concerned, for example by informing or educating the author or reviewer, or by issuing a letter of warning.

Major Misconduct

Serious cases may lead to one or more of the following outcomes: publication of a correction or retraction, a formal notice of misconduct, notification of the author's or reviewer's institution or funding body, and a ban on submissions to the journal for a defined period. The journal may also refer the case to COPE for advice.